
This is a re-posting of a blog I posted over two years ago. I will endeavour to update it soon but many of the core concepts I still fully endorse.
(Disclaimer: Please understand this is a huge ideology squeezed into a small stream-of-consciousness rant. It represents a sudden and massive (although apparently slight) shift in my ideals. It is not without reproach no doubt. I have been brief, fleeting and even lackadaisical on some points. But a core truth is there that perhaps you will see. If not, I am happy to further discuss any aspect of this with any person to the benefit of us both hopefully… given the whole “unexamined life not worth living” and all )
I have for a long time been aware of these Anarchy Heart symbols and thought they were a refreshing re-invention of an ideal that expresses my own political ideologies. The bastardisation and demonisation of anarchism as a concept into a violent, aggressive, chaotic way of being has been a clever piece of misdirection and had me begin to regard anarchic symbology with some degree of discomfort. For what use is a symbol that does not represent your ideals. But with this interesting conjunction I believe others have come close again. The only name I found for this movement was the rather awkward Lovearchy. A strange mix of English and ancient greek roots that seems to lose the original importance of the word anarchy. So I am putting forward my own little playful attempt.
agapetic-anarchism: [Greek root] the absence of rulers (an-archos) through the practice of unconditional altruistic love (agape).
This is a practice that many great Christian anarchists have leaned towards (Tolstoy, Kierkegaard) but failed due to their desire to be both anarchistic and Christian specifically rather than concentrating on being anarchic and practising the core tenats of the Christian faith, avoiding alignment with a specific religious label and hence invoking my-god-can-beat-your-god-in-a-fight separatism.
I do not propose any great revolution either in or towards my ideals. In fact I propose we have already won as it were. This path is unavoidable. It is more a question of when rather than if…
Anarchism of this kind is the natural evolution of society. Power employed for the controlling of the masses to the advantage of the few will only be sustained so long. Society constantly evolves towards the empowerment of the many. This struggle comes in waves but the general trend is towards a sharing of responsibility.
A final attempt to hold on to Power is then for the purposes of protection in relation to a lack of faith in humanity. Those that are willing to trust themselves and perhaps their closest neighbour but not all neighbours due to the concern that humans are ‘naturally’ greedy, selfish et al. This is the parental care system of governing and is notably highlighted in terms of the oft-mentioned ‘Nanny-State’. This is more sustainable a power because the parental care and protection can be considered loving to the extent that our best interest are at heart. The paralleling analogy however offers the evidence to the contrary. A child that spends their whole life sheltered by such an over-bearing parent is decidedly damaged by the experience. They tend to be limited in their capacity to effectively deal with the remainder of society due to their fear of them (the ‘I don’t trust them’ syndrome before mentioned) and they are also thereby limited in their capacity to love others; creating an ongoing spiral of distrust, retraction and emotional/sociological stunting. This very same process is clearly causing most (if not all) the illnesses of society. As (for our own safety) we are taught to separate ourselves from Other we become isolated and disconnected. At an individual level this causes a large number of problems but when protracted through the masses this tendency towards isolation promotes tribalism, greed, property, boundaries, borders, state and eventually hatred, violence, war and poverty.
If the circulatory system contains blockages the results are devastating. Or for another example you need only look at the damage caused by blocking the natural tendency for water to find its own way in the ‘wild’ to the overall ecosystem. We provide short term benefits to a limited few but at the cost to the whole system. So by setting up a state border we protect our own interests by controlling (to a given extent) a fraction of society but damage mankind’s capacity to embrace everything outside that border. Try as we might. I am not even allowed to cross it without written permission from those on either side for heavens sake! I will not go into a long rant as to the failures of the world that have derived from such boundaries and compartmentalising (black, white, British, Irish, American, Muslim, woman, man, working class, Christian, homosexual, heterosexual and so on) – The evidence for the incredible and horrifying atrocities that have happened in name of these labels is so painfully apparent to everyone I will not begin to scale this mountain. But for our own safety we need these boundaries right? The logic again and again brought to bear here is the notion that it isn’t me that I am concerned about. No. Rather these limits need to be in place to control them, the scarey people that aren’t like you and me, (like these global terrorists – who are in fact responsible for only a minute fraction of the indiscriminate killing that is done in our name). This is the primary error. There is and never should be considered to be a ‘they/them’. Our denial of our essential ‘oneness’ is not just the route of a disassociation with effective religious practice but it is the route of dysfunctional society in general. And still all the dysfunctions of that society are continually held up as proving the need for such continuing controls.
The only way to evolve is to accept than no human has the right to dominion over any other and the free flow and optimisation of our society can only when it works as a whole from the core of a single route source. This argument is often put forward by tyrannist’s, in that, where there is a single leader, that leads for the benefit of all effectively, one can have a successful polity. But this will fail for so many reasons. Not least of all because of our innate similarity, i.e. we are all human. There is no cause to reason that all other humans for all time would consent to the absolute rule of another of their stock as it were. Humans are not absolute, certainly not from the viewpoint of individualism. A necessary viewpoint when placing a human at a political zenith (or indeed any zenith). So perhaps we can be ruled by an absolute? An abstract outside of individual limitation. This absolute would be indisputable and abundant and shared by all. Time and time again this has been put forward as a solution; that solution specifically being God. And Islam, Christian fundamentalists among others would like to take this model for sure. But we do not share God. God is a subjective concept whether or not God is in fact an objective entity. We do not ‘give’ one another God. Rather we offer notions of God, paths to God, rules from God, lessons of God, images of God, normally differing, and as such God has become as divisive, if not more so, that many other aspects of society. But there is something, behind the religious experience and the grasping at the divine, that does have relevance and we have failed to keep this revelatory truth hidden in the convoluted complexities of religion. The one thing that we do share, and offer each other day and daily, that is absolute and when perfectly practiced our true salvation; is Love.
Love, total and utter altruistic love of the self first. Then the realisation that we are not separate from the Other and hence the love of all things second. And finally the realisation that we are not separate from the Infinite and hence the love and acceptance of all aspects of creation comes and all that exists within it including time, energy, flux and death and even for my part the actions of all those who thwart our progression towards our perfect evolution. This is our world. It is what we make it and it is what we have made it. And so I make my final point.
I looked outward to the world for change but no more. This is not revolution but evolution. Like the magician, I am my world, and the true anarchist will make every change he needs to internally. I know many who read this will take the clear and simple view that it will not happen. “We will not all come upon this manner of thinking and all act in this way, not everyone, at the same time, it just isn’t possible. I do not to believe it is possible. Sure it would be nice if everyone was suddenly loving to everyone else all the time and all but it just isn’t realistic.”
Well I believe it is possible and I am not alone. And by believing it to be possible I make it so … in part. I will do my part of the whole that is needed to make it actual. That is all I can ask of myself. I believe it will free us all. I believe that it is the end to which all other ends lead and as such is unavoidable. I believe at some point in space-time it has indeed come to be, and there is only a question of how and when we get there. And for my part. Knowing I have done my part. I will be content.
That being said everyone loves their parents no matter how badly they mess you up So I thank everyone with political aspirations for any and all their good intentions, whether they be chains or not, and realise I have been a rebellious teenager for too long. You also now have my love.
So remember:
Love knows no masters
Love is sacrificial in nature
Love is non-judgemental
Love cannot be controlled
Love is non-violent
Love cannot be owned
Love cannot be sold
Love cannot be restrained
Love can never be depleted
Love is always there, for all mankind, it binds us and can never be otherwise.
Love can indeed (to quote the old adage) set us free but only when we love freely.
All the Love to you all,
Cavan
![The Mushroom [ themushroom.net ] The Mushroom [ themushroom.net ]](https://www.themushroom.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/mushroom_logo_new-2.png)
April 2, 2011 @ 2:05 am
A comment that I received to the above blog and my response:
COMMENT:
But isn’t Love, like God, open to free interpretation by individuals thus leading to the exact same situation were various prophets, leaders and “Churchs of Love” will each give different advice and dogmas on what is and isn’t love and how it should/shouldn’t be expressed. Is it love to bring euthanasia to the very sick and old? Or is it love to treat and nurse them right to the end no matter what the pain?
Essentially this idea is good, but it has far too many problems surrounding the interpretation and implementation of Love in ordinary mundane and boring situations that make up life.
Posted by Sociรฉtรฉ Royale d’Horticulture on 02 Dec 2006, 16:58
MY RESPONSE:
Well yes and no. Love as a concept is open to interpretation via its observation but not its practice. The point is that your love is yours to give. This does not prevent an assumed prophet or other individual making a judgement upon your expression of love but this in no way alters the validity of your subjective intentions. Is it love to bring euthanasia to the very sick? Answer: The individual in the situation that this precise decision relates to WILL know. There is no absolute or objective answer. In exactly the same way that no individual can be pigeon-holed and effectively live under the same rules as every other person. The very issue I referred to before of compartmentalising…
There is no requirement for interpretation of the processes of Love. It may or may not be done with the awareness of external parties or even our own awareness, but this is entirely irrespective of the implementation of Love. This implementation comes as naturally as breathing. Yes we can think about it. Alter it. And use it in different ways. Be at the core it is a process we simply need to let happen.
April 2, 2011 @ 2:06 am
Well, I’m not sure what to say. Sounds like John Lennon’s philosophy.
I am not sure whether every individual WILL know what is the best thing to do in any given situation. Sounds a bit absolutist to me. Everybody does what they think is best, I guess. What is right is another matter. Whoever said love was non-judgemental. The ability to make clear, rational judgements is an important human faculty. What is important is not to be a hypocrite.
Love cannot be sold – many people, like therapists do sell their time, and offer therapeutic loving. I think an altruistic love of self is a contradiction in terms. Doesn’t altruism mean acting for the benefit of the other?
And boundaries – are they not good and useful? At a certain stage of development anyway. Animals have boundaries. Through boundaries we find out what is acceptable and unacceptable to another. Boundaries are important both in morality and physical space. I think this kind of oneness mysticism misses out on the dimension of our individuality. Sure we are all one – but we are also separate and different as well. The truth is somewhere between the two.
About authority and power – people need authority until they can own it for themselves. It is wise to submit to the authority of a motor mechanic if your car breaks down and you know nothing about engines. There can be abuse of authority and power and I guess that is what many anarchists are worried about. Some things need to be changed internally but I would not rubbish external change. Showering, shaving and tidying your room are important. I guess what you mean is restricting change to things within your direct control.
Someone once gave me some good advice – stick with what is.
Tolstoy decided to follow his ideal of communism and left his house to wander to some unknown destination. He died of cold.
Beware of magical thinking – there is some truth in it yet reality persists…..
April 2, 2011 @ 2:10 am
First off, I am not sure about the precise nature of Tolstoy’s death at the ripe old age he made it to (note: he was a Christian Anarchist not a Communist) and I understand the warning I think; echoing Aristotle’s remarks on the importance of practical wisdom as well as contemplating the divine so as to avoid being the wise man that falls down the well whilst concentrating on the heavens… but his ideals were perfectly aware of practicalities in ‘reality’ surely, or how would Ghandi have implemented them so effectively! He is a great role model of mine. His aimless wanderings certainly may have been the cause of his death but his ‘wonderings’ on the other hand had plenty of aim and purpose :o)
Now, “beware of magical thinking”, why? “There is some truth in it but reality persists”. Yes of course it does but not in any kind of objective, knowable, sensible way. Mystery persists also. There is danger in accepting mystical ideology as a total alternative to rationalism but I don’t do that. I use reason to develop an understanding of the rational and I use intuition and subjective gnosis to apprehend the Wyrd. Nothing is ‘True’, all we have are our beliefs and the level to which they have practical value; but there is value in believing the irrational in many circumstances. Obviously this is a huge discussion so I will move on for now but I have more to say about this if you want to discuss it further.
Its a really old adage but “there is nothing to fear but fear itself” has proved to hold a great deal of truth in my life and so I heed the warning but choose not to be concerned. :o)
Right your points on anarchism … lots of good ones! Everyone certainly doesn’t do what is right but I believe everyone knows what is right (of course I can’t know that – it goes without saying – this is a faith issue). And what is right for them may not be right for another, or may not seem right to an observer. This is part of the difficult nature of Being. I am NOT a Utopian in the traditional sense. I am not a hippy either. Conflict, pain, and chaos are an intrinsic part of the greater Whole. In fact I believe everything that is happening right now to be essential to the evolution of humanity and the ultimate anarchic end I seek. However, that includes my devotion to the ideal laid out above.
Essentially when I say that a person will know what is right I am putting my faith in the individual, in all individuals… not being afraid of others’ actions and therefore protecting myself from them by limiting said individuals’ authority, by restraining their actions and delivering power to a few. This seems illogical to me. Are those few better served to make the decisions of an individual? No. They cannot be aware of all the complexities. Do I think there is a chance an individual can make the wrong choice? Sure! This is exactly why the choice of an individual should not dictate to the masses! Thinking based on fear of what that individual may do with the full extent of their power can only serve to damage our own interests. And as I have already said I choose to not be afraid. Of course this happens to include the fact that I am not afraid of what politicians are doing now – but I digress) The simple issue is – how can one politically equal individual ever be better served to make a decision on what another politically equal can and cannot do? The very nature of politics makes it extremely difficult to allow these people to do what they know is right because they must first serve what is politically advantageous in order to retain their power.
The ability to make rational judgements is an enormously important human faculty; as is the power to make irrational judgements. The power of faith cannot be denied. The ability to believe irrationally has also contributed heavily to human evolution.
Therapists offer a service for money but that service is not love. It is a procedure. A procedure, task or service can be undertaken with love but it can also be undertaken without love. The love itself is not bought and sold. Take as another example money cannot buy Happiness. This is true. It can indirectly just like your example of the therapist. Money can buy the opportunity to experience Happiness but happiness itself is innate and so cannot be transferred and as such cannot be bought or sold as this infers
transfer. The same is true of love.
Altruism is a devotion based on selflessness. It is concerned with the welfare of others yes. How is this a contradiction? Agape is normally understood as the love of God, or Buddha or whatever … I simply mean the same. I mean the love of ‘Other’ as opposed to ego-based love. The two are in fact the same but ego based loved has attachment and often people expect to be considered good or goodness in return and such. Altruistic love is a devotion that denies the ego and as such benefits All.
You very sensibly separate authority and power. I do not believe I have referred to authority at all in my previous rant. Perhaps you know that authority isn’t something the anarchist objects to. We object to rulers. We object to the coercive. We object to power. Authority is given. Power is taken. Of course I may invest authority in someone temporarily if that again serves my interests and I reserve the right to do so and take it back just as readily. Can I take back the power the state has over me? Did I ever consent? No. There can be abuse of authority but this is something I have enacted. Abuse of power is a grave injustice and one to which I shall never submit.
There is so much more I want to say. But I feel I have got the ball rolling as it were…
I look forward to your (and anyone else’s – feel free to join in ;o) ) response.
All the Love,
Cavan
April 2, 2011 @ 2:12 am
I agree with an awful lot of what you have written in these two rants. But the only thing i fear is that everyone pulling together, in the same direction, with the same sense of altruism can then be completetly ruined by one act by one person…
April 2, 2011 @ 2:14 am
Indeed. This is why full spectrum anarchism is an end rather than a viable immediate alternative. It is a final destination wherein the journey towards provides us with more and more liberty. The ‘powers’ that be are clamping down for sure but this is still part of a general trend towards our liberation. What annoys me about those supporters of the status quo that sneer at left politics is that so many of the current freedoms and reforms they hold dear have fought and won by idealistic libertarians. The problem on the other hand with the left is that they often do not keep striving for more. Until we have achieved this, albeit seemingly unlikely goal, we should never rest in our pursuit of true equality for all. The only alternative is to be part of the problem. Don’t forget if you told a 17th century peasant in the feudal system of the freedoms of a modern citizen they would never believe it could happen – don’t let the apparent unlikelihood dilute your ambition.
I believe :o)
This one person you speak of would be acting selfishly … this happens now but I am talking about an end wherein the consensuses understanding is that one best serves the self by serving the whole. This will require a fundamental shift in human conciousness and interaction.
All of this WILL happen. And I will take my place as part of the movement towards this end. I can ask no more of myself….
Be great to see you sometime mate. Big Love!